After being introduced by a mutual friend in the winter of 2000, Reform Rabbi Ammiel Hirsch and Orthodox Rabbi Yosef Reinman embarked on an unprecedented eighteen month e mail correspondence on the fundamental principles of Jewish faith and practice What resulted is this book an honest, intelligent, no holds barred discussion of virtually every hot button issue on whicAfter being introduced by a mutual friend in the winter of 2000, Reform Rabbi Ammiel Hirsch and Orthodox Rabbi Yosef Reinman embarked on an unprecedented eighteen month e mail correspondence on the fundamental principles of Jewish faith and practice What resulted is this book an honest, intelligent, no holds barred discussion of virtually every hot button issue on which Reform and Orthodox Jews differ, among them the existence of a Supreme Being, the origins and authenticity of the Bible and the Oral Law, the role of women, assimilation, the value of secular culture, and Israel.Sometimes they agree often than not they disagree and quite sharply, too But the important thing is that, as they keep talking to each other, they discover that they actually like each other, and, above all, they respect each other Their journey from mutual suspicion to mutual regard is an extraordinary one from it, both Jews and non Jews of all backgrounds can learn a great deal about the practice of Judaism today and about the continuity of the Jewish people into the future.From the Hardcover edition.
One People Two Worlds A Reform Rabbi and an Orthodox Rabbi Explore the Issues That Divide Them After being introduced by a mutual friend in the winter of Reform Rabbi Ammiel Hirsch and Orthodox Rabbi Yosef Reinman embarked on an unprecedented eighteen month e mail correspondence on the fu
I went into this book expecting a balanced debate between the Reform rabbi and the Orthodox rabbi, with the Reform rabbi defending elements of my own liberal Judaism. I ended the book with far more empathy towards the Orthodox rabbi and more than a little embarrassment about the Reform rabbi.Throughout the book, Orthodox Rabbi Yosef Reinman describes an Orthodox Judaism that is more loving and less strident or closed to the world than we often hear our Reform rabbis tell us from the bimah. He di [...]
An interesting examination of the orthodox and reform approaches to G'd, Israel and family lifeThis fascinating book follows a year long email correspondence between an Orthodox and Reform rabbi from NJ and New York, respectively, as they debate the theology, philosophy and ethics of their views on a diverse range of topics, with scriptural and Talmudic evidence to back them up. The conversation is robust and sometimes snarky - surprisingly the more moderate and compassionate voice comes from th [...]
I found the book to be an entertaining and interesting snapshot in time, depicting the gap between Orthodox and Reform versions of Judaism. It's already a bit dated, 10+ years after it was written, which actually added to its appeal for me. R' Reinman somewhat dominates the discussion, and therefore the book, and he tends to be speaking to the reader as opposed to R' Hirsch, while Hirsch seems to be speaking directly to Reinman. I think a moderator with some editorial control could have made thi [...]
A very educational book! While I expected equal discussion from each rabbi, the Orthodox--or Classical--rabbi stole the show. His explanations were erudite, passionate, and backed up by Torah and Talmud. The Reform rabbi, while equally passionate and erudite, often fell back into some of the criticisms that liberal Jews have towards their more observant brethren. Both men had their assumptions about the other but, by the end of the book, many of these had been overcome. Certainly not all of them [...]
I had some trouble getting through this book, but almost exactly half of it - that is, I found the Orthodox writer to be increasingly condescending, rhetorically slippery, sarcastic, and sanctimonious. I suppose he did get his perspective as an Orthodox Jew across, even with all that, so there's that. The Reform rabbi, on the other hand, was much more pleasant to read, and also much more consistent and particular in his arguments and ideas, and there's a certain satisfaction each time he rebukes [...]
Really well done. Easy to go with pre-conceived notions- but all both points of view frequently well done. Braod choice of issues- role of women, role of orthodox in reform, G-d written or G-d inspired text, gay rights-- and more. worth reading more than once
A somewhat awkward debate between an Orthodox rabbi and a Reform rabbi (both males). Some valid points are made with appropriate sources provided. I'm doing a lot of underlining in pencil and thinking. Fairly good read so far.
As a practicing Jew for my entire life, this book significantly altered the way I view some facets of Judaism. I often suggest this book to anyone I encounter who is undergoing any type of transitional process within his or her practicing/understanding of Judaism.
"One people, two worlds : an Orthodox rabbi and a Reform rabbi explore the issues that divide them by Ammiel Hirsch (2002)"
If you are interested in understanding the differences between Orthodox Jews and Reform Jews, this is the best book I found on the subject.
Great concept, and very enlightening. It's a book that reminds us that even the most emotional debate can be had in a civil way if by mensches like these two Rabbis. A very worthwhile read.
Pathetic, superficial and dogmatic discussion. I absolutely gain no valuable insights on the topics included. Some good points.